The Pro Farmer

Pro Farmer

Stop Struggling. Start Growing.

Disclaimer: For information only. Always follow the EPA-approved label. Read full disclaimer here

Vibrant cherry tomatoes and fresh basil leaves, perfect for a healthy salad.

How to Grow Basil: With Tomatoes, Marigolds & Why It Turns Black

Basil is the easiest herb to grow – and the easiest to kill. Everyone has bought a beautiful basil plant from the store, put it on the windowsill, and watched it turn black in a week.

It’s not you. It’s 3 mistakes: too much water, too cold, and never pinching.

If you grow it right – with tomatoes and marigolds – it grows bushy all summer, and your tomatoes taste better too.

1. Which Basil to Grow?

In the US you will see 4 types in the nursery:

  • Genovese Basil – the classic Italian basil. Big green leaves, best for pesto and Caprese. This is what you want for tomatoes.
  • Thai Basil – purple stems, anise flavor, for Asian cooking. Beautiful, but not for pesto.
  • Lemon Basil – small leaves, lemon scent. Good for tea and fish.
  • Holy Basil / Tulsi – smaller, stronger flavor, mostly for tea.

For tomatoes – grow Genovese. That’s the one in all the recipes.

>> See: Burpee Genovese Basil Seeds

2. Which Tomato Seeds to Buy? Plant Them Together

In the US most gardeners grow tomatoes from seeds, not from seedlings. Start basil and tomatoes at the same time, indoors, 6-8 weeks before last frost. Then transplant both together in May.

For beginners – buy these from Burpee:

  • Better Boy – the classic American hybrid. Big, disease-resistant, gives a lot. If you grow one tomato, grow this one.
  • Big Beef / Beefsteak – the big slicing tomato for sandwiches. Every American knows Beefsteak.
  • Roma / San Marzano – small, meaty, not watery. Best for sauce and pasta.
  • Sungold – orange cherry, super sweet. Kids love it. The most popular cherry tomato in the US.
  • Sweet 100 – red cherry, gives 100 tomatoes on one plant.
  • Brandywine – pink heirloom, old-fashioned flavor. For growers who want something special.

>> See: Burpee Tomato Seeds – Better Boy, Beefsteak, Roma, Sungold

That’s the full collection – pick 1 slicing + 1 cherry. Don’t buy 6 varieties for your first year.

3. Which Marigold Seeds to Buy? Don’t Skip This

Marigolds are not just for beauty. They are your pest control.

Which marigold to buy:

  • French Marigold – small, bushy, blooms fast. Best for repelling nematodes around tomatoes. This is the one you want for vegetable beds.
  • African Marigold / Crackerjack – tall, big flowers, for borders and ends of beds.
  • Signet Marigold – tiny flowers, edible, for pots and edges.

For tomatoes + basil – buy French Marigold. It’s the one that actually repels root-knot nematodes.

>> See: Burpee French Marigold Seeds

Plant marigold seeds at the same time as basil and tomatoes – indoors, 6-8 weeks before last frost. Transplant all three together in May. One bed, three plants.

My layout:
Tomato in the middle, basil on both sides, French Marigold at the ends and corners.

4. When to Plant Basil

Basil loves heat. It hates cold more than any other herb.

Don’t plant basil until nights are above 50°F / 10°C. If you plant in April and there’s one cold night – it’s dead. Wait until May, after tomatoes.

Seeds sprout in 5-10 days at 70°F / 21°C. From seed to plant ready for first picking takes about 6 weeks.

If you buy a plant from the store – don’t plant it as-is. That pot has 20 seedlings crowded together. They will choke each other. Split it into 3-4 plants and replant with space.

5. Where to Plant – Sun, Soil, Spacing

Sun: Full sun, 6-8 hours minimum. Basil in shade gets leggy, pale, and tasteless.

Soil: Rich, well-drained, with compost. Basil is a heavy feeder – it wants food like tomatoes do.

Spacing: 12 inches / 30 cm apart. If you plant too close, no airflow – black leaves and fungus.

Pot: If you grow in a pot, use at least 1-gallon pot per plant. One plant per pot. Not 5 plants in one small pot.

6. Basil + Tomatoes + Marigolds – The Classic Trio

This is not a myth. It works, and here’s why:

Basil + Tomatoes:

  • Basil attracts bees and pollinators to your tomatoes – more tomatoes, better pollination
  • Basil repels thrips, whiteflies, and tomato hornworm moth – fewer pests on tomatoes
  • Some growers swear basil improves tomato flavor. I can’t prove it in a lab, but my tomatoes with basil always taste better.

Plant basil 12 inches from the tomato stem, on the sunny side. Don’t plant it under the tomato where it gets shade.

Marigolds + Tomatoes + Basil:

  • French Marigolds repel root-knot nematodes – the tiny worms that kill tomato roots. African Marigolds are pretty but less effective for this.
  • Marigolds attract beneficial insects – ladybugs, hoverflies – that eat aphids on basil and tomatoes
  • Marigolds bloom all summer, so pollinators keep coming

My layout for one tomato bed:
Tomato in the middle, basil on both sides, marigolds at the ends and corners. One bed, three plants, almost no pests.

Read my full tomato guide here: /garden-lawn/how-to-grow-tomatoes/

7. How Much to Water?

Basil wants consistently moist soil – not wet, not dry.

How do you know you are overwatering?
Leaves turn yellow from the bottom up, stems get soft and black. That’s root rot. Stop watering, let soil dry 1 inch down.

How do you know there is lack of water?
Leaves wilt in the afternoon, then recover at night. If they wilt every day – water more.

Water in the morning, at the base, not on the leaves. Wet leaves at night = black spot fungus.

Don’t guess. Use a moisture meter.

>> See: Soil Moisture Meter – same meter I use for tomatoes and cucumbers.

8. Fertilizer – Why Basil Turns Yellow

Basil is hungry. If you don’t feed it, leaves turn pale yellow and small.

Use compost at planting, then add slow-release fertilizer. That will carry you for 2 months.

>> See: Espoma Garden-Tone 3-4-4 – what I use for basil, tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers. One fertilizer for everything.

Don’t use high-nitrogen fertilizer only – you get big leaves with no flavor. Balanced fertilizer is better.

9. Pinching – The #1 Secret to Bushy Basil

If you don’t pinch, basil grows tall, thin, flowers, and dies. That’s it.

How to pinch:
When the plant has 6-8 leaves, cut the top stem just above a pair of leaves. Two new stems will grow from that point. In 2 weeks, pinch those two again. In a month you have a bush, not a stick.

Never let it flower. Once basil flowers, leaves turn bitter and small. If you see flower buds – pinch them off immediately.

Harvest rule: Never pick more than 1/3 of the plant at once. Pick from the top, not the bottom leaves. Picking from the top forces bushy growth.

10. Why Is My Basil Turning Black?

This is the question everyone asks. 4 reasons:

1. Cold: Below 50°F / 10°C, leaves turn black overnight. Bring pots inside, cover plants in garden.

2. Overwatering / Root Rot: Soil stays wet, stems turn black from the bottom. Let soil dry, improve drainage.

3. Downy Mildew: Yellow spots on top, gray-purple fuzz underneath. This is the disease that kills basil in humid summers. Remove infected leaves, improve airflow, don’t water on leaves. Full guide here: /pests-fungi/downy-mildew-yellow-spots-treatment/

4. Fungus from wet leaves: Watering at night, leaves stay wet. Water in the morning only.

If your basil is already black and mushy – it’s done. Start a new plant. Don’t try to save it.

11. Harvest – How to Keep It Alive All Summer

Pick every 3-4 days, a little bit each time. Regular picking = bushy plant.

Best time to pick is morning, after dew dries, before heat. That’s when oils and flavor are strongest.

How to store: Don’t put basil in the fridge – it turns black. Keep cut stems in a glass of water on the counter, like flowers. For winter, make pesto and freeze it in ice cube trays. Dried basil loses most flavor.

12. Pests on Basil

Aphids: Small green/black bugs on new growth. Blast with water, or insecticidal soap: /pest-insects/get-rid-of-aphids-on-tomatoes/

Whiteflies: Small white flies that fly up when you shake the plant. Full guide: /pest-insects/get-rid-of-whiteflies-on-plants/

Spider Mites: Tiny dots, fine webbing, leaves turn bronze in heat. Full guide: /pest-insects/get-rid-of-spider-mites-on-tomatoes/

Slugs: Eat leaves at night. Use copper tape around pots, or beer traps: /pest-insects/get-rid-of-slugs-and-snails/

Don’t spray chemical insecticide on basil you are going to eat today. Use soap or water first.

FAQ

Why is my basil leggy?
Not enough sun + never pinched. Move to full sun, pinch top, and it will bush out.

Can I grow basil indoors all year?
Yes, but you need a sunny windowsill – 6 hours sun – or a grow light. Indoor basil in winter is thin and weak without light. Better to grow new plants from seed in spring.

Should I plant basil with tomatoes?
Yes. 12 inches from tomato, on sunny side. Basil attracts pollinators, repels pests, and you harvest both together for Caprese.

Does basil really improve tomato flavor?
Growers swear it does. Science is not proven. What is proven: basil brings bees to tomatoes, repels pests, and saves you space. Even if flavor is a myth, it’s worth planting.

How long does basil live?
One season. Basil is annual. It will flower and die in fall. Save seeds or start new plants next spring.

Why did my store-bought basil die?
That pot has 20 seedlings crowded. Split it, replant with space, give sun, don’t overwater. Store basil is grown for sale, not for long life.

Which tomato seeds should I buy first?
For beginners: Better Boy for slicing + Sungold for cherry. Both from Burpee. That’s enough for your first year.

Which marigold seeds should I buy for vegetables?
French Marigold. Not African. French is the one that repels nematodes around tomatoes.

You might also like these articles:

error
fb-share-icon

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WhatsApp
Verified by MonsterInsights